2005 MINI hatch: common problems and MOT failures

What goes wrong more than usual on a 2005 MINI hatch?

Parts flagged at MOT more often on the 2005 MINI hatch than on all cars registered in 2005.

• Engine oil leaks2.3× usual
  MINI hatch

  33.7% All 2005 cars

  14.5%

  Failed outright at MOT: 0.6%, against 0.3% of all 2005 cars. The rest were advisories or minor defects.

  Rough price £80–£600 our estimate

  At the viewing: Look under the engine and where the car is usually parked for fresh oil. Ask whether the leak has been looked at.

• Rigid brake pipes2× usual
  MINI hatch

  30.5% All 2005 cars

  14.9%

  Failed outright at MOT: 5%, against 2.4% of all 2005 cars. The rest were advisories or minor defects.

  Rough price £100–£400 our estimate

  At the viewing: Ask to see underneath, or check the MOT advisories: corroded brake or fuel pipes get worse every year and fail the MOT when they do.

• Sub-frame2.4× usual
  MINI hatch

  16.2% All 2005 cars

  6.8%

  Failed outright at MOT: 0.6%, against 0.3% of all 2005 cars. The rest were advisories or minor defects.

  Rough price £300–£1,000 our estimate

  At the viewing: Look underneath at the frame the suspension bolts to. Flaky rust or holes are expensive to fix.

• Suspension arm2.4× usual
  MINI hatch

  9.9% All 2005 cars

  4.1%

  Failed outright at MOT: 0.9%, against 0.4% of all 2005 cars. The rest were advisories or minor defects.

  Rough price £120–£180 (one arm) ClickMechanic

  At the viewing: Listen for clunks over bumps and feel for the steering wandering. Worn arm bushes show as cracked rubber near the wheels.

• Power steering pipes and hoses8.1× usual
  MINI hatch

  6.5% All 2005 cars

  0.8%

  Failed outright at MOT: 0.4%, against 0.1% of all 2005 cars. The rest were advisories or minor defects.

  Rough price £100–£400 our estimate

  At the viewing: Ask to see underneath, or check the MOT advisories: corroded brake or fuel pipes get worse every year and fail the MOT when they do.

Common 2005 MINI hatch MOT failures and advisories

The share of 2005 MINI hatch MOT tests where testers flagged each area, as a fail or an advisory. Rough prices are typical independent-garage costs.

• Brakes
  53% of testsRough price £150–£350

  At the viewing: Look for a lip on the disc edges and feel for judder or pulling when braking firmly from about 40mph.

• Suspension
  48% of testsRough price £120–£400

  At the viewing: Listen for knocks over speed bumps, and look behind each front wheel for a snapped coil spring.

• Lights and electrics
  40% of testsRough price £10–£80

  At the viewing: Ask a friend to check every light, including brake lights and indicators, while you operate them.

• Oil and fluid leaks
  36% of testsRough price £80–£600

  At the viewing: Look under the engine and on the ground where the car is usually parked for fresh oil or fluid.

• Tyres
  31% of testsRough price £70–£150

  At the viewing: Check the tread on all four tyres, including the inside edges, and look for cracks or bulges.

• Exhaust and emissions
  14% of testsRough price £100–£1,200

  At the viewing: Look for black soot in the tailpipe, listen for blowing from the exhaust and check for engine or DPF warning lights.

Known faults on the 2005 MINI hatch

Reported by owners, mechanics and buying guides for this model and age. Check which engine the car has, as some apply to one engine only.

• Head gasket and liner problems (1.4 diesel)

  1.4 diesel

  The 1.4 Toyota-made diesel is prone to head gasket and cylinder liner problems.

  At the viewing: Check the coolant level and colour, and look for smoke from the exhaust.

  Source: Parkers: MINI Hatchback (2001-2006) used review

• Oil leaks and brittle plastics (1.6 petrol)

  1.6 petrol

  The 1.6 petrol can leak oil from the sump and cam cover gaskets. Plastic parts go brittle; if the dipstick handle breaks and falls into the sump it can wreck the engine.

  At the viewing: Look for oil around the engine and underneath, and check the dipstick handle is intact.

  Source: Parkers: MINI Hatchback (2001-2006) used review

• Low oil pressure after servicing

  Petrol

  Low oil pressure can mean the cartridge oil filter was fitted wrongly at the last service.

  At the viewing: Make sure the oil warning light goes out straight after starting, and listen for tapping from the engine.

  Source: Parkers: MINI Hatchback (2001-2006) used review

• Gearbox bearing and differential noise

  Manual gearbox

  Early cars used a Midland gearbox where a rattle or hum can mean a worn bearing, and clicking can mean a failing differential. The later Getrag box (from mid-2004) wears less but shouldn't jump out of gear.

  At the viewing: Listen for rattles at idle and hums on the move, and make sure every gear engages and stays in.

  Source: Parkers: MINI Hatchback (2001-2006) used review

• Misfires and worn engine mounts

  Petrol

  Worn coils or leads, or oil in the spark plug wells, cause misfires. Worn engine mounts cause judder when pulling away.

  At the viewing: Check it idles smoothly and pulls away without judder.

  Source: Parkers: MINI Hatchback (2001-2006) used review

• Water leaks and damp boot

  All engines

  The frameless front windows can seal badly, and the rear lights and tailgate handle trim often let water in.

  At the viewing: Lift the boot floor and check for damp or a musty smell.

  Source: Parkers: MINI Hatchback (2001-2006) used review

• Rust on neglected cars

  All engines

  Neglected cars can rust at the rear sill edges, around the front bumper and in the arches.

  At the viewing: Look along the sills and wheel arches for bubbling paint.

  Source: Parkers: MINI Hatchback (2001-2006) used review

Questions to ask the seller before buying a 2005 MINI hatch

Ask before you travel to see it. A seller who knows the car will have answers, and receipts.

1. Has the head gasket ever been replaced, and does it lose coolant?
2. Any recent work on the engine oil leaks? (Flagged at MOT 2.3× as often on the 2005 MINI hatch as on other cars the same age.)
3. Any recent work on the rigid brake pipes? (Flagged at MOT 2× as often on the 2005 MINI hatch as on other cars the same age.)
4. Any recent work on the sub-frame? (Flagged at MOT 2.4× as often on the 2005 MINI hatch as on other cars the same age.)
5. Can I see the service history and receipts for any big jobs?